On April 9, the Shincheonji (New Heaven New Earth) Church of Jesus in France released an official statement criticizing the April 7 article published by the French daily Le Parisien, stating that the church and its members were “seriously defamed” due to distorted and biased reporting.

The church pointed out that the article excessively highlighted one-sided claims made by a former member, while barely reflecting the actual practices and beliefs of the faith community.

The controversial article, titled “They Treated Us Like Animals”, described New Heaven New Earth Church as one of the “problematic evangelical groups” in France, based on the personal testimony of an anonymous former member. The article mentioned training camps, severed personal relationships, and monetary demands. However, the church emphasized that their position was reflected in only two sentences of the article.

A church representative stated, “We submitted a detailed written response consisting of thousands of words to 12 questions sent by the reporter in advance, but only two sentences were used in the article. That’s less than 1% of our full statement and severely limits readers’ ability to see a balanced perspective.” The representative also noted, “Since the article was published only four hours after we submitted our responses, it seems the report had already been pre-written with a biased intention.”

They added, “If the written statement was insufficient, the reporter could have visited the church in person to observe our faith practices and hear directly from active members. Our church is always open to communication with the media.”

To provide a more accurate picture, the church shared testimonies from current members. Teresa (29), who has attended the church in Paris for six years, said, “Faith is something one chooses voluntarily. Through this church, I learned who God is and how to live as a light in the world.” Another member, Axel (30), said, “Before joining New Heaven New Earth Church, I was searching for meaning in life. Through my faith here, I’ve come to understand what God desires from us, and I find great joy in doing God’s work. I’ve even been able to travel and met my wife at church. I’m living a truly fulfilling life.”

Regarding the article’s sensational title, “They Treated Us Like Animals”, the church stated, “Our members were shocked and confused by this phrase. No one in our community has ever been treated that way, nor do they feel that way. This was clearly a provocative headline used to attract attention.” The church emphasized that it does not tolerate threats or stigmatization of former members and respects individuals’ decisions even after leaving the church.

In response to the claim that “the church forced a breakup between a woman and her boyfriend,” the church strongly denied this, saying, “The man was also a member of the church at the time and even expressed interest in marriage. However, the woman stated she wasn’t ready for marriage. Their breakup was a personal decision based on mutual discussion and faith considerations, and the church never pressured or influenced their relationship.” They added, “Dating and marriage are personal matters based on autonomy and responsibility; it’s inaccurate to attribute them to church control.”

The church also raised concerns about misleading content in the interview. One example cited was a photo showing someone with their foot on a radiator, which the article described as “punishment.” The church explained, “This photo has nothing to do with punishment. It was taken before the individual even joined the church. The person in the photo, who is still a member today, was simply demonstrating a pose for fun, and the image was taken lightheartedly. The member was shocked by the article’s misuse of the photo without consent and intends to file an official complaint with the media outlet.”

The church stated, “Reporting such claims without proper fact-checking fosters a skewed perception that the entire New Heaven New Earth Church of Jesus is irrational, which is extremely regrettable.”

Concerning the so-called “training camps,” the church clarified, “These were short-term, completely voluntary programs for individuals who desired deeper spiritual growth. They included morning prayers and Bible meditation. Participants could leave at any time, and there was no physical punishment or coercion involved. However, understanding that it might be misunderstood from an outside perspective, the church has since discontinued the program.”

The church also refuted claims about collecting personal information, restricting internet access, or encouraging members to cut family ties, stating, “None of this is true. We only collect minimal information needed for faith counseling. There are no restrictions on internet usage or external relationships. On the contrary, we encourage our members to live exemplary lives within their families and communities.”

Regarding the use of the name “ECA Academy,” the church explained, “It was a Bible education program name temporarily used in 2019. Participants were clearly informed that it was affiliated with New Heaven New Earth Church of Jesus, and joining the church afterward was entirely up to the individual.”

In response to the article, the New Heaven New Earth Church of Jesus in France called on the media to uphold the following principles:

• Include a variety of perspectives and experiences in reporting
• Accurately reflect the church’s official responses and statements
• Provide fair opportunities to share the experiences and voices of active members
• Respect religious freedom and the dignity of believers
• Avoid sensational titles and expressions that foster prejudice

A church representative concluded, “Biased reports targeting specific religious communities impose stigma and prejudice on sincere believers, violating religious freedom and human rights. The media must avoid inflammatory approaches that incite hatred and instead aim for balanced, respectful coverage that represents diverse voices.”

They added, “We hope Le Parisien and all media outlets adhere to higher ethical standards in religious reporting. New Heaven New Earth Church of Jesus remains committed to open communication and honest dialogue to foster better understanding.”